May 21, 2023 8 min read

If you’re looking for the best-fitting polo shirts then you’ve come to the right place. Polo shirts are a versatile pieces of clothing halfway between casual and formal. You can wear them with crisp chinos and dress shoes for a formal office fit. 

You can also dress it down a polo shirt with swim shorts for beach styles or tucked into jeans for a more casual, everyday look.

If you have an athletic body then the polo shirt is one of the most flattering casual items you can wear. The key to polo shirts looking great is a perfect fit. It’s common for men to opt for relaxed shirts. 

However, if you want to look fashionable and enhance your physique, then a streamlined silhouette that's fitted but not too tight will get you there. A tapered short sleeve can also show off your arms in a flattering way.

In this article, we suggest some of the best-fitting polo shirts we have on offer, and why they’ll work for you. We’ve also written a buyer’s guide to help you pick the wheat from the chaff so you know what you’re looking for.

Keep reading to find out more.

What this article covers:

How to Select the Right Polo Shirt

To select the right polo shirt for a specific occasion, you need to consider fit and fabric. So, how should polo shirts fit? If you're looking for a polo shirt that’s for a casual occasion, then you can choose either a loose-fitting polo shirt or a tighter one. Either one is appropriate for a casual event.

 best slim fit polo shirt

Cotton is always a good choice for wearing year-round, however, for the colder days, a knit polo cut from wool or cashmere will keep you warm while looking stylish. 

Fortunately, there are many different varieties of polo shirts available nowadays. You can choose between different colors, patterns, and designs. You even get men’s athletic fit polo shirts for athletic body types. Here are 11 of thebest fitting polo shirts to accentuate your physique and keep you comfortable. 

11 Best Fitting Polo Shirts

TAILORED ATHLETE Slub Open Collar Polo Shirt

Our Slub Open Collar Polo Shirt is made from a super soft cotton fabrication with a textured feel. It features a refined retro styling and is cut with an open collar. It’s an easy-to-style staple that caters to the athletic physique. 

It comes in slate blue, washed coral, and pebble colors, making it the perfect option for a Summer’s day out. You can pair this with chino shorts for an elevated summer style.

best fitting polo shirts

It’s designed with our True Muscle Fit, 4-way stretch, and raglan cut sleeves for ultimate comfort and style. It’s also machine washable and made from 92% Cotton and 8% Spandex, giving it a long lifespan.

TAILORED ATHLETE Merino Open-Collar Long Sleeve Polo Shirt

This Long Sleeved Merino Open Collar Polo Shirt uses premium merino wool for a soft handle and luxury finish. It’s woven with a lightly textured feel and enhanced with a signature True Muscle Fit, so the garment lays flatteringly on your form.

best fitted polo shirts

You can pair this shirt with Chinos or Trousers for sophisticated Spring/Summer styling. It’s also available in the colors black, slated blue, and chalk.

It’s crafted from stretch fabric and has raglan-cut sleeves. It’s also 100% Merino wool and machine washable.

TAILORED ATHLETE Stripe Chest Zip Polo Shirt

Our Stripe Chest Zip Polo is crafted from 100% luxurious cotton and finished with a subtle stripe design for a modern take on casual styling. It features raglan sleeves and a zip neckline. 

You can wear this sophisticated polo shirt with trousers and trainers for a tailored off-duty edit. It’s available in pearl grey, has a True Muscle Fit, stretch fabric, and is super soft.

best dry fit polo shirts

TAILORED ATHLETE Jersey Buttonless Polo Shirt

Effortlessly improve your wardrobe with ourJersey Buttonless Polo Shirt, a timeless classic. It’s made from super-soft stretch cotton and raglan-cut sleeves.

It comes in blue melange, giving it a light feel and subtle touch, and is ideal for smart/casual-cool styling. Pair it with any of your basic jeans or trousers to match any occassion. 

With a True Muscle Fit and stretch fabric, it’s purposely designed to accentuate your physique. It’s also conveniently machine washable and made from a blend of 95% cotton and 5% elastane.

TAILORED ATHLETE Printed Open Collar Polo Shirt 

The Printed Open Collar Polo Shirt is crafted from a ultra soft fabrics, enhanced with our signature True Muscle Fit to keep you looking fresh. The monochrome geometric print draws the eyes, so you’re sure to stand out against the crowd. 

The moisture-wicking and anti-wrinkle properties make it perfect for long summer days. 

best fit polo shirts

It comes in a geo-print color and pattern that can be easily complemented with tailored shorts for casual styling.

The 4-way stretch, raglan sleeves, and shape retention make it super comfortable. It’s made for convenience as it’s machine washable, quick drying, and anti-wrinkle. This shirt is also crafted with a blend of 95% Polyester and 5% Spandex.


The Split Hem Polo Shirt is made from a new luxuriously soft interlock fabric, giving it a buttery soft, clean finish. The high quality fabric means it retains its shape over time, even as it stretches to fit larger muscles. 

Its refined details and minimal branding provides a clean finish, keeping you looking understated but still stylish. Our signature ‘True Muscle Fit’ keeps your silhouette as the main focus. 

For the modern athlete, this polo shirt can be dressed up or down depending on the occasion. It’s available in colors oatmeal and slate blue.

best fitting men's polo shirts

It features 4-way stretch, and raglan sleeves, is machine washable, and is made from a comfortable blend of 47% Cotton, 47% Viscose, and 6% Spandex.

TAILORED ATHLETE Color Block Knit Polo Shirt

This Colour Block Knit Polo Shirt is crafted from pure luxurious cotton, finished with a modern color block design that takes advantage of the eye-catching trend to highlight your features. It’s made with our signature True Muscle Fit, raglan sleeves, and a zip neckline.

best men's fitted polo shirts

It’s available in navy and you can wear this sophisticated polo shirt with trousers and trainers for a versatile edit.

It’s designed for comfort as it’s made from 100% cotton, stretch fabric, and is super soft and lightweight.

TAILORED ATHLETE Pique Long Sleeve Polo Shirt 

The Pique Polo Long Sleeve Polo Shirt is the ultimate casual luxury piece. Its lightweight piqué fabric is knitted from 100% cotton and provides a soft hand feel. 

The long sleeves mean that it’s perfect for the colder months, so you can enjoy the style and versatility of a quality polo shirt year-round.

best slim fit polo shirts

It features a ‘True Muscle Fit’ which guarantees a physique-enhancing finish. It has premium styling details adding a modern twist to what is considered a classic. You can elevate your wardrobe with this wardrobe staple.

It’s best when paired with trousers or jeans for a casual look.

TAILORED ATHLETE Tipped High V Knit Polo Shirt

This is a classic Tipped High V Knit Polo Shirt reinvented with a buttonless neckline and sophisticated contrast tipping at the collar and side seam for a modern finish. The subtle detailing adds a level of style without becoming distracting, so you can stand out without looking garish.

It’s made with raglan sleeves and natural stretch so it will fit around your muscles rather than making you look like you’re stuffed into your clothes. 

It’s easy to dress up or down by pairing it with jeans or chinos depending on the occassion. 

best fitting mens polo shirts

TAILORED ATHLETE Mercerised Tipped Zip Polo Shirt

Our Mercerised Tipped Zip Polo is made from super soft pure cotton. The zip neckline and contrast tipping gives it a modern and sophisticated look, making it great to wear out on the greens or at an office event. 

The raglan-cut sleeves are designed to accentuate your physique and give you True Muscle Fit.

This navy shirt is best worn with a pair of chinos for a timeless look.

It has a 4-way stretch, is ultra soft, and is machine washable. It’s also made from 100% mercerized cotton.

best men's dri fit polo shirts

Which Fabric Is Best for Polo Shirts?

Polo shirts suit all shapes and sizes, however, it’s necessary to consider the type of material the shirt is made from before making your selection. 

Pique cotton shirts are crafted with cotton yarn with a slight ribbing in it. Piqué polo shirts are best suited if you are heavier with a wider physique. This is because the textured fabric hugs the body without accentuating the less flattering areas of the chest and stomach.

If you want to show off your body, then cotton and cotton blend polo shirts are the perfect choice. This kind of fabric is softer and more comfortable than pique cotton. A cotton blend polo shirt has a sleek, modern look that is great on its own or worn underneath a jacket. 

You can also check out the best polo shirts for muscular guys.

It’s usually better to stick to a plain polo shirt when you first start wearing them. Black, white, navy, and grey offer the most versatility because they work with most skin tones and body types. 

When you’ve tried neutral colors, you can then start to widen your horizons by checking out the wide range of colored polo shirts on the market. Stripes and patterns are also good choices. Remember to choose a color that complements rather than clashes with your skin tone or hair color. 

 fitting polo shirts

How to Wear a Polo Shirt

There are some simple rules to follow when wearing a polo shirt. If you’re wearing one without a jacket then don’t tuck your shirt into your pants or trousers. 

If you are wearing a jacket with the polo underneath then you could tuck in the front part of the shirt a little so it partially covers your belt. This looks fashionable without being over the top. 

Your polo shirt should be fitted but not too tight. It’s too big if there’s a lot of slack material on your body. Good quality polo shirts are made from lighter materials like cotton. They should drape nicely over your body without showing too many lumps and bumps. You can look at the difference between polo slim fit and classic fit shirts.

Don’t wear anything underneath as polo shirts look best when directly on the skin. You can tailor the shirt to your height but the tail of a polo shirt shouldn’t hang down any further than midway past your behind. Check out the best athletic fit polo shirts if you have an athletic build.

 dry fit polo shirts

Pockets and Collars

Pockets and collars are crucial details in your choice that can make a big difference to the overall look. Polo shirt collars are usually either soft or tailored more like a shirt.   

Soft collars do sometimes curl up at the edges, so you may wish to opt for a collar with an additional lining sewn in. This helps the collar to lie flat.

Polo shirts with pockets sometimes look saggy. The pocket itself is also quite useless as a practical addition. Try to go for a smooth-fronted polo with no pockets.

You can wear a polo shirt with any combination of trousers. When paired with a polo shirt, anything looks good and can easily be dressed up or down to suit the occasion. 

Did you find our blog helpful? Then consider checking:

Leave a comment

Comments will be approved before showing up.



Your location is set to Europe

  • Shop in your native currency
  • Get shipping option for Europe
Go to Europe site →